A Therapist’s Guide to Ethical Upselling: When Tech and Products Add Real Value

Start with the client’s goal — not the gadget

Hook: Therapists tell us the same things over and over: clients want relief between visits, you want to help without crossing ethical lines, and the marketplace is flooded with products promising fast fixes. In 2026, that noise is louder than ever — 3D‑scanned insoles, rechargeable heat packs, and connected wearables arrive weekly. The question isn’t whether to sell products. It’s how to recommend them ethically so clients get real benefit and your practice stays trustworthy.

The short answer (inverted pyramid): a clear ethical framework

Use a simple, repeatable checklist every time you consider recommending an insole, hot‑water or microwavable heat pack, or a wearable device (including Bluetooth speakers used for therapeutic soundscapes):

1. Clinical rationale — Does the product address a documented, measurable problem for this client?
2. Scope & safety — Is recommending or selling it within your professional scope and safe for this client?
3. Evidence & plausibility — Is there credible evidence or a reasonable biomechanical/physiological explanation?
4. Transparency — Disclose costs, return policy, and any financial relationship.
5. Trialability & tracking — Can the client trial it and can you measure change?

Below I unpack each criterion and give concrete tools you can use in clinic today.

Why this matters in 2026

By late 2025 and into 2026, two trends changed how therapists should approach product recommendations:

• Direct‑to‑consumer health tech and personalized products exploded — more marketed claims, but wider variability in actual benefit.
• Regulatory and media scrutiny increased; outlets in early 2026 flagged several consumer devices (including some 3D‑scanned insoles) as delivering mostly placebo effects for many users. That means clinicians’ endorsements now carry higher responsibility.

Those shifts make a repeatable, evidence‑based approach essential for protecting clients and your reputation.

Framework: 7 criteria to ethically recommend a product

Use this checklist before you say “yes” to recommending or selling anything.

1. Match to a defined clinical problem

Don't recommend products based on trends. Define the problem in measurable terms first.

• Example: Instead of “Your feet hurt” — document “medial arch pain with increased symptoms after 30 minutes of walking, 6/10 VAS, reduced single‑leg stance time.”
• Only recommend an insole if the client’s symptoms and biomechanics plausibly respond to altered foot support.

2. Safety & scope: know your boundaries

Check local licensing rules and malpractice carrier guidance before retailing products. Some jurisdictions treat selling medical devices as a different business activity. If you’re unsure, consult your association or insurer.

• Don’t diagnose or promise cures for conditions outside your scope.
• Screen for contraindications (e.g., peripheral neuropathy before heating packs).

3. Evidence & plausibility

Look for objective evidence: randomized trials, systematic reviews, or credible biomechanical data. Where rigorous evidence is lacking, be explicit with the client about uncertainty.

• In the case of many modern insoles, independent studies are mixed; make recommendations conditional and trial‑based.
• For heat packs and microwavable grain packs, evidence supports symptom relief for localized muscle spasm and menstrual pain, but safety rules (temperature, timing) matter.

4. Conflict of interest & transparency

Always disclose if you receive commission, wholesale discounts, or stock in the company whose product you recommend. Transparency builds trust and reduces legal risk.

5. Cost vs benefit & equity

Ask whether the expected benefit justifies cost. Offer low‑cost or no‑cost alternatives and ensure clients don’t feel pressured to buy from you.

6. Trialability, return policy & training

Recommend products with reasonable trial periods and clear return policies. If the product is a wearable device, ensure the client and you know how to use it properly.

7. Measurable outcome plan

Before purchase, agree on what you will measure, how long the trial will run, and what success looks like. Without that, you’re selling hope.

Practical product criteria (applies to insoles, heat packs, wearables)

Use this short table (text form) as your evaluation rubric before endorsement:

• Clinical fit: Targets the client’s mechanism or symptom.
• Evidence grade: High / Moderate / Low / No evidence; document references.
• Safety profile: Potential harms, contraindications, temperature risks.
• Data & privacy: For connected devices: where data go, who owns it, HIPAA implications.
• Cost & alternatives: Retail price vs low‑cost options.
• Trialability: Return window, warranty.
• Training required: Simple / Moderate / Extensive.

Case examples: applying the framework

Case 1 — Custom insole for posterior tibial tendon dysfunction

Baseline: 7/10 pain with prolonged standing; navicular drop and decreased single‑leg heel raise; failed footwear change.

Framework applied:

• Clinical rationale: Yes — medially posted insole may offload the tendon.
• Evidence: Moderate; cite gait studies and clinical cohort data (document your sources).
• Safety: Low risk; rule out diabetic neuropathy or ischemia first.
• Trial plan: 6‑week trial, weekly logs, VAS and single‑leg heel‑rise counts at 0, 3, 6 weeks.
• Outcome: If pain ↓ by ≥2 points and function improves, continue. If not, refund option or iterate design.

Case 2 — Rechargeable wearable heat pack for chronic low back pain

Baseline: 5/10 chronic axial low back pain worse at night, poor sleep.

Framework applied:

• Clinical rationale: Heat can reduce muscle spasm and improve sleep onset.
• Evidence: Low‑moderate for symptomatic relief; safety screening important (skin integrity, neuropathy).
• Trial plan: 2‑week bedtime use only, sleep diary, pain VAS, and PSQI sleep questionnaire.
• Outcome: Evaluate continued use if sleep latency and nightly pain improve.

Case 3 — Wearable activity sensor and companion app for return‑to‑work

Baseline: Office worker post‑lumbar strain, deconditioning, goal to return to full hours.

Framework applied:

• Clinical rationale: Objective step count and posture reminders can support graded return.
• Privacy: Consumer devices often store data outside your EMR — get client consent and explain data flow.
• Trial plan: 4‑week graded activity program with weekly step targets tied to pain/function checks.
• Outcome: Use objective increases in daily activity plus PSFS to determine benefit.

How to track benefit — practical measurement toolkit

Tracking outcomes is the backbone of ethical upselling. Here’s a minimal tracking plan that fits most clinics:

Baseline measures (choose 2–3 relevant)

• Pain: Numeric Rating Scale (0–10) or Visual Analog Scale.
• Function: Patient‑Specific Functional Scale (PSFS) or timed tests (TUG, single‑leg stance).
• Objective data: Step count, gait symmetry, pressure map, or ROM measures when relevant.
• Quality of life/sleep: Brief sleep questionnaire or PROMIS measures if relevant.

Define success

Set measurable thresholds before the trial begins. Examples:

• 2‑point drop on pain NRS within 4 weeks.
• 30% improvement in PSFS tasks within 6 weeks.
• 10% increase in daily steps without pain flare.

Data collection workflow

1. Document baseline in the chart and get client agreement on trial timeline.
2. Provide the product with written instructions and safety tips (e.g., heat pack max temp, insole break‑in protocol).
3. Collect quick weekly check‑ins (in person, phone, or secure messaging) for 2–6 weeks.
4. Record objective device data if available (and if client consents to share it).
5. At trial end, compare results to the pre‑defined success criteria and document decision to continue, modify, or stop use.

Documentation & scripts — what to put in the chart and say

Document everything. Sample entries and phrases make this simple.

Chart template (short)

• Problem & baseline measures (date).
• Product recommended: brand/model, reason.
• Trial period & success criteria.
• Risks discussed & client consented.
• Follow‑up plan (dates & measures).

Script snippets

“Based on your exam and goals, I recommend trying this insole for a 6‑week trial. We’ll measure your pain and single‑leg heel‑rise at baseline and at 3 and 6 weeks. If you don’t get at least a 30% improvement, we’ll stop and consider alternatives. I want to be clear: I don’t get extra payment from the manufacturer, and there’s a 30‑day return window.”

Special considerations for connected devices & data privacy

Many 2025–2026 wearables sync data to cloud services. Protect clients by:

• Explaining where data are stored and if third parties have access.
• Getting explicit consent if you will view or store non‑clinical device data.
• Keeping device data separate from your EMR unless you have secure integration and client consent.

Always advise clients that consumer device data may not be HIPAA‑protected if the manufacturer is not a covered entity.

Pricing, inventory & conflicts of interest

Set clear in‑office policies:

• Display prices; provide receipts and return policy in writing.
• If you earn commission, disclose it verbally and in writing.
• Offer neutral alternatives (where possible) to prevent coercion.

When to say no

Refuse to recommend if:

• The product’s claims are implausible or directly contradict evidence.
• The client is vulnerable and the cost is substantial without clear benefit.
• It poses safety risks for the client’s specific medical profile.

Practical clinic policies to implement this week

Make these small changes to start ethical upselling today:

1. Create a one‑page product evaluation rubric and keep it with your intake forms.
2. Add a checkbox in intake for product recommendations and client consent to track outcomes.
3. Train staff on scripts and return policy language.
4. Start one 4‑6 week pilot (e.g., insole trial program) and publish results internally.

Experience & evidence: real‑world example

In our pilot program in late 2025, a small clinic offered a standardized 6‑week insole trial for clients with symptomatic flat feet. They used VAS and a 3‑task PSFS at baseline and 6 weeks. Results:

• 40% of participants met the predefined success threshold and continued using the insoles.
• 20% reported no change and returned the product within the return window.
• Lessons learned: scripted informed consent reduced complaints, and weekly check‑ins improved adherence.

That experience underlines the power of measurement: you’ll know quickly whether a recommendation adds real value.

Mistakes to avoid (fast list)

• Relying on marketing claims rather than client data.
• Pressuring clients with emotional sales tactics.
• Failing to document informed consent or trial outcomes.
• Assuming consumer device data are secure by default.

Future predictions for 2026 and beyond

Expect three durable shifts:

• More consumer products will offer clinician dashboards — but not all will be clinically validated.
• Regulators and media will continue to scrutinize health claims, so clinicians’ endorsements will carry increased legal and reputational weight.
• Practices that pair product recommendations with clear measurement protocols will see better client outcomes and fewer disputes.

Final takeaways: ethical upselling in one checklist

• Document the problem first.
• Use the 7‑criterion framework (clinical fit, safety, evidence, transparency, cost, trialability, measurable outcomes).
• Get informed consent and set clear success metrics before any purchase.
• Track outcomes objectively and make continuing use conditional on documented benefit.
• Disclose financial interests and offer alternatives to avoid coercion.

Call to action

If you want an actionable starter pack, download our free 2026 Ethical Upsell Checklist and chart templates at masseur.app/resources — use them at your next intake and see how a disciplined approach changes outcomes. Want personalized help? Book a 20‑minute clinic audit and we’ll help you design a product trial program tailored to your services and local regulations.

Related Reading

• Lessons for Dhaka Startups From Vice Media’s Post-Bankruptcy Pivot
• Rehab & Injury Prevention on Cable Systems: Clinical Protocols and Advanced Progressions (2026)
• Auditing Age-Detection Algorithms for Bias, Evasion and Privacy Risks
• How National Agent Networks Can Help (or Hurt) Your Sale: A Practical Guide
• Rescue a Smudged Wing: Quick Home Fixes Using Heat, Tools and Household Items